Growing up in the Sugarcreek area in the 70s and 80s, and even when I moved back with my wife in the early 90s, there just weren’t many places to stay in Amish Country, Ohio. It didn’t matter if you wanted to stay in Berlin, Walnut Creek, Sugarcreek, Millersburg, or Mt. Hope, you had limited choices.
Over the last 25 years, there have been many additions when it comes to places to stay in Amish Country, Ohio. The hard part now isn’t finding a place to stay. It’s choosing between all the great options.
My goal in this post is to give you some of the best places to stay in Amish Country so you can make the best decision for your situation.
I’ve personally visited or researched every option on this list, so you’re getting real picks, not just a rehash of what everyone else is writing about.
Types of Accommodations in Amish Country, Ohio
There are many different types of accommodations you can stay at when coming to Amish Country. You can stay at a hotel, inn, vacation rentals, bed and breakfasts, tree houses, boutique style places and cabin stays.
Hotels and inns: Hotels and inns can be found all throughout Amish Country, Ohio. You will find ones that are traditional in nature and others that have a more modern flair. Many have pools and hot tubs to help you relax.
Bed and breakfasts: Most bed and breakfasts in Amish Country, Ohio are cozy, rustic, or romantic experiences. Many have wonderful views of the surrounding area and have fantastic home cooked breakfasts.
Vacation rentals/Cabins: You have a wide variety of vacation rentals to choose from when staying in Amish Country. There are rustic log cabins, private suites, and charming cottages.
Unique Stays (treehouses, farm stays, boutique): If you are looking for unique stays in Amish Country, there is no shortage of great places. You can choose modern treehouses, quiet farm stays, and luxury boutique hotels.
Best Areas to Stay in Amish Country, Ohio
Berlin — Best for First Time Visitors
Berlin is the heart and central hub of Amish Country and the best place to stay if this is your first visit. You’ll find the largest selection of shops, restaurants, and attractions here, and many hotels are within walking distance of downtown. Staying in Berlin makes it easy to explore the surrounding towns without long drives.
Walnut Creek — Best for Scenic Views
Walnut Creek is known for its rolling farmland and beautiful countryside views. It’s quieter than Berlin but still close to great shopping, bakeries, and restaurants. Many hotels here sit on hillsides, giving you some of the best sunrise and sunset views in Amish Country.
Sugarcreek — Best for Families
Sugarcreek is a great choice for families thanks to attractions like the Ohio Star Theater, the cuckoo clock, and several family friendly restaurants and shops. The area has a slightly more modern feel while still keeping Amish Country charm. It’s also conveniently located for exploring nearby towns.
Millersburg — Best for Historic Charm
Millersburg offers a mix of history, local shops, and a quieter small town feel. It’s home to the historic courthouse square and several museums, making it a good fit for visitors who enjoy history and a slower pace. Staying here also puts you close to many scenic backroads and countryside drives.
Map of Places to Stay in Amish Country, Ohio
Use this map to see where each lodging option is located throughout Amish Country, including Berlin, Walnut Creek, Sugarcreek, Charm and Millersburg.
Best Unique Places to Stay in Amish Country, Ohio
The Inn at Honey Run (Near Millersburg)
- Price Range: $$$
- Best For: Couples
When I think of the Inn at Honey Run, I think of class. It is an adults only boutique resort that feels genuinely unlike anything else in the area. They have 3 different types of rooms to choose from including the unique honeycomb rooms that are built right into a hillside. Beyond the rooms, the property has an onsite restaurant and a Holmes County Open Air Art Museum with walking trails throughout the grounds. Oh, and there is a flock of Tunis sheep you can feed.
Cricket Hill Treehouses (Near Millersburg)
- Price Range: $$$
- Best For: Couples
You may have dreamt of sleeping in a treehouse as a kid, but I am sure your dreams were not of the luxury treehouse experience you get with Cricket Hill Treehouses. With six custom built treehouses ranging from 22 to 30 feet off the ground, each one comes with a private hot tub overlooking a ravine or pond, a fully equipped kitchen, and separate dining and living areas. Swiss Family Robinson never had it so good.
Berlin Resort (Berlin)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Families, couples, groups
The Berlin Resort has some features that makes it unique from other lodging options in Amish Country. There is a 26 seat private movie theater, the only hotel in Ohio that has a private theater, a miniature village for kids to explore, and a 17,000 sq ft fitness and wellness area. People have high ratings for the grounds which include fish ponds, waterfalls, and gardens. The resort is also located a short drive from popular restaurants and shops.
Guggisberg Swiss Inn (near Charm)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Families – Couples
The Guggisberg Swiss Inn sits on top of a hill which gives you fantastic panoramic views of the Doughty Valley. There are 24 rooms in the inn with 3 different room types. Horses roam freely around the grounds of the inn and you can saddle up for intimate guided trail rides for two or four riders. They have an on site winery with estate wines named after each horse on the property. The made from scratch breakfast gets high marks from guests.
Best Amish Country Bed and Breakfasts
Miller Haus Bed & Breakfast (near Walnut Creek)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Couples
The Miller Haus B&B is a wonderful place to unwind and get away from it all since the rooms don’t have TVs or phones. They do have wifi if you need to have a tech fix. The property has a large wrap around porch that gives you beautiful views of the countryside. There are 9 rooms with 3 different room types to select from. Guests are served a multi-course breakfast in a common dining area. Homemade desserts and beverages are served every evening.
The Barn Inn B&B (Near Millersburg)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Couples
You can always tell people you slept in a barn if you stay at The Barn Inn B&B, since the inn is inside a beautifully restored 1919 barn. There are 11 themed rooms with 6 suites to select from. Each morning you get a scratch made rotating breakfast and the owner of the inn provides a morning presentation of the history of the area, as well as recommendations for visiting the area.
The Charm Countryview Inn (Near Charm)
- Price Range $$
- Best For: Couples
The Countryview Inn is a true technology detox destination. There are no TVs in the 15 rooms. They don’t have wifi and there is no cell service when you stay at the inn. What the inn lacks in technology it makes up for with spectacular views from the large wrap around porch of meadows, gardens, and Amish farms. A full homemade country breakfast is served Monday-Saturday with a continental breakfast served on Sundays.
Best Cabins and Vacation Rentals in Amish Country, Ohio
Donna’s Premier Lodging (Berlin)
- Price Range: $$$
- Best For: Couples, anniversaries
If you are looking for a romantic getaway in Amish Country, Donna’s Premier Lodging is a fantastic choice. They offer romantic cabins, chalets, and villas designed with couples in mind. Rooms have whirlpool tubs, fireplaces, and private decks for a secluded Amish Country escape. People give it high marks for feeling very secluded but also being within walking distance to downtown Berlin.
Hillside Hideaways (Near Berlin)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Couples, families
Hillside Hideaways sits between Millersburg and Berlin and is known as one of the cleanest vacation rentals in the area, with cozy cottages featuring ponds, hillside views, and private outdoor spaces perfect for unwinding after a long day of exploring. They have options for couples looking for a romantic escape as well as larger cottages that work well for families, which makes it one of the more versatile picks on this list.
Tranquil Acres Cabins (Near Millersburg)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Couples, anniversaries, honeymoons
Tranquil Acres Cabins are beautiful log cabins nestled in the woods in the heart of Holmes County, rated 5 out of 5 on TripAdvisor and ranked among the top specialty lodging in the Millersburg area. Each cabin features a whirlpool tub for two, a remote controlled gas fireplace, a fully equipped kitchen, and nature trails right on the property overlooking a fishing pond. Guests come back year after year and it is easy to see why once you are tucked into these woods just minutes from Berlin and Millersburg.
Best Hotels in Amish Country, Ohio
Carlisle Inn (Sugarcreek)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Families, couples
I have the most experience with the Carlisle Inn since I have stayed there and my wife worked there part time. The inn has 69 rooms that have modern amenities with Amish craftsmanship. The inn is unique from the others on this list since it is located on a 55 acre campus which has Dutch Valley Restaurant and Bakery, Ohio Star Theater, Dutch Valley Gifts, and Dutch Valley Market. Make sure to get a cream stick at the bakery. You won’t be disappointed.
Carlisle Inn (Walnut Creek)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Families, couples
I have stayed and been to numerous events at the Carlisle Inn Walnut Creek. It is a more traditional and laid back hotel versus the Sugarcreek location. There are 52 rooms that feature Amish craftsmanship. To me the standout feature of this hotel is the spectacular views of the farming valleys. Rooms have balconies with rocking chairs to take in the scenery. Personally, I’m more partial to the valley view in the rear of the hotel. When you book, request a room on that side and you won’t regret it.
Berlin Grande Hotel (Berlin)
- Price Range: $$
- Best For: Families, large groups, business travelers
The Berlin Grand Hotel is unique for Amish Country because of its contemporary modern style. It has an urban decor with a double crystal fireplace, a locally crafted staircase, and a heated saltwater pool. The hotel has a real city feel to it with the down home customer service experience you would expect for the area. If you love to shop and eat at great restaurants, the hotel is a great choice since you don’t have to drive to do those things.
Best Budget Friendly Options in Amish Country, Ohio
Dutch Host Inn (Sugarcreek)
- Price Range: $
- Best For: Budget travelers, families, groups
This quaint 33 room inn is owned and operated by a Mennonite family and is known for its exceptionally clean rooms with furniture crafted by local Amish artisans. I live a mile away from the hotel and I have never stayed there, the reputation speaks for itself. When we visited Acadia National Park the operator of the horse carriage rides inside the park told us he buys his horses in this area and always stays at the Dutch Host Inn. When someone travels from Maine to stay there, that tells you everything you need to know.
Inn at Walnut Creek (Walnut Creek)
- Price Range: $
- Best For: Budget travelers, couples, shoppers
Located in the heart of Walnut Creek, the Inn at Walnut Creek offers a welcoming atmosphere with clean, comfortable rooms at a great value, with guests appreciating its quiet central location just steps from shops, bakeries, and the Walnut Creek Cheese store.The hotel really punches above its weight value wise. Make sure to get a room on the backside of the hotel for beautiful sunset views.
When to Visit Amish Country & Booking Lead Times
| Season | Travel Vibe | Recommended Booking Window |
|---|---|---|
| Early Fall (Sept – Oct) | Peak Season: Vibrant foliage and harvest festivals. Expect heavy crowds. | 6–12 months for specialty stays; 3–6 months for hotels. |
| Late Fall (November) | Shoulder Season: Crisp air, lingering foliage, and pre-holiday shopping. Quieter than October. | 1–2 months in advance. Weekends near Thanksgiving may need 3 months. |
| Early Dec (Dec 1 – 20) | Mini-Peak: Holiday lights, Christmas shopping, and theater shows. | 2–4 months for weekends; 1 month for mid-week. |
| Summer (June – Aug) | High Season: Family vacations, warm weather, and county fairs. | 3–6 months for weekends; 1 month for mid-week. |
| Spring (March – May) | Shoulder Season: Blooming flowers and moderate crowds. | 1–3 months in advance. |
| Winter (Jan – Feb) | Slow Season: Quiet retreats, snowy landscapes, and best lodging deals. | Last-minute to 2 weeks in advance. |
Pro Tips
- Mid-Week Advantage: Visiting Tuesday through Thursday often results in lower room rates and far fewer crowds than weekends.
- Sunday Closures: Most Amish owned businesses and many restaurants are closed on Sundays for religious observance, so plan your itinerary accordingly.
- Heavy Traffic: Traffic during Peak and High Season can be heavy during the day in the Berlin, Walnut Creek, and the Sugarcreek areas.
- Speciality Packages: Many lodges offer special packages throughout the year, especially during the off season, that include dining vouchers, gifts from local shops, and other regional perks.
What to Look for When Choosing a Property in Amish Country
Think about where you want to stay. If shopping and eating at restaurants in Berlin and Walnut Creek is important, you’ll want to look for lodging in those areas because it will make your days simpler. If peace and quiet is what you are after, then staying in a cabin or B&B outside of town should be your focus.
Before you book your stay, here are some key questions to ask any property.
- Is breakfast included and what does it typically consist of?
- What is the cancellation policy?
- Are there special packages available for anniversaries, honeymoons, or holidays?
- Is there a minimum stay requirement on weekends or holidays?
- Are pets allowed on the property?
- Is the property accessible for guests with mobility concerns?
- Is there parking on site and is it free?
- Are there any extra fees not included in the nightly rate?
How to Use Credit Card Points to Stay in Amish Country
A great way to save money when you travel is by using credit card points. My wife and I have saved thousands of dollars over the last few years on our hotel stays. The savings can be significant, especially during peak fall season when rates climb. There are a number of national chain hotels in Amish Country where you can use credit card points to cover your stay.
Amish Country has properties affiliated with three major hotel loyalty programs.
- IHG One Rewards
- Choice Privileges
- Wyndham Rewards
You’ll want to check to see if you can book your stay with points, if you have points with any one of these programs.
If you are not sure which hotel card is right for you, my guide to choosing the best hotel credit card walks you through the whole process.
If you aren’t sure about credit card points but you want to learn more, I have a beginner’s guide to credit card points that will answer many of your questions.
Getting the Most Out of Your Stay in Amish Country, Ohio
Best Restaurants in Amish Country
One of the reasons that people come to Ohio’s Amish Country is to enjoy the food. There are a lot of excellent restaurants in the area. I have put together a list of the 10 best restaurants that you can enjoy when you come to Amish Country. From traditional Amish buffets to local landmark diners, there is something on the list for every appetite.
Things to Do in Amish Country
Another major reason that people come to Amish Country is the variety of things that you can see and do. I have put together two different posts that can help you find something to enjoy while you are in the area.
It doesn’t matter if you are watching your budget or looking to fill every hour of your trip, between the two posts you will have more than enough to keep you busy.
Planning Your Amish Country Trip: Common Questions Answered
Berlin is about 106 miles from Columbus, which works out to just over 2 hours by car. From Cleveland you are looking at about 74 miles and roughly an hour and a half. Pittsburgh is the furthest of the three at around 107 miles, putting you at about 2 hours and 15 minutes depending on your route. All three cities make Amish Country very doable as either a day trip or an overnight getaway.
This is one of the most important things to know before you visit. Most businesses, shops, restaurants, and markets are closed on Sundays, so if you are planning your big shopping day or counting on eating at a specific Amish restaurant, do not save it for Sunday.
That said, Sunday is actually a wonderful day to drive the back roads and take in the scenery. Plus, traffic isn’t an issue on Sundays. Some of the chain restaurants and larger properties stay open. Think of Sunday as your slow down and scenic drive day and you will not be disappointed.
Honestly you could spend a long weekend and still not see everything. Two nights and three days is a sweet spot for most visitors. That gives you enough time to explore the main towns, hit a few restaurants, do some shopping, and actually slow down and soak in the experience. If you are a shopper or a foodie you could easily fill four or five days. I have lived here my whole life and I am still finding new things to enjoy.
Absolutely. Kids love it here and honestly it is one of the best places you can take them. Where else can they watch a horse and buggy roll past while they are eating a fresh donut? The Berlin Resort with its miniature village, movie theater, and expansive grounds is a natural fit for families. Add in farm stays, cheese factories you can tour, and wide open countryside and you have plenty to keep kids engaged without a single screen involved.
There are some pet friendly options but it is not universal, so always call ahead before you book. The Dutch Host Inn for example does not accept pets, and several of the B&Bs have the same policy. Your best bet for traveling with a pet is to look at vacation rental cabins where pet policies tend to be more flexible. Hillside Hideaways and some of the private cabin rentals in the area are worth checking for pet friendly availability.
Yes, several do. The Berlin Grande Hotel has a heated saltwater pool, the Berlin Resort has a heated saltwater pool, and the Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek has a heated pool. The Carlisle Inn at Walnut Creek doesn’t have a pool but you can use the pool at the Sugarcreek location. If a pool is important to your stay it is worth confirming directly with the property since hours and availability can vary by season.
Final Thoughts
It doesn’t matter if you are coming to Amish Country, Ohio as a solo traveler, with your family, as a couple, or with friends. There is no shortage of great places to stay no matter your budget or travel style. You have traditional hotels and inns, bed and breakfasts, cabins, treehouses, and vacation rentals.
You can find places in the heart of towns that allow you to walk to restaurants and shops. While other lodging options allow you to be away from the hustle and bustle so that you can unwind and relax.
I may be a little biased since I grew up here, but I truly believe Amish Country is one of the most underrated destinations in the Midwest. Once you visit, I think you will agree.
